Which type of auction should I use?
There are four ways to run the bidding. Each works whether you are buying or selling. The right one depends mostly on how many serious bidders you have and how clearly you can describe what you want.
The short answer
- Start with sealed bids unless you have a reason not to.
- Use a live auction when you have three or more comparable bidders and a clear specification.
- Use a Dutch or Japanese auction when you have only one to three bidders and want it settled in minutes.
Find your situation
I am not sure, or this is my first one
Sealed bids
It is the simplest for you and for bidders, works with any number of them, and is hard to get wrong.
Three or more bidders who can all supply the same, clearly specified thing
Live auction
Bidders see how they rank and push each other. Competition does the negotiating for you.
Only two or three bidders, or I expect their prices to be far apart
Dutch auction
Nobody knows what the others will accept, so each must decide their real price without a rival to shadow.
One or two serious bidders, and I suspect there is room in their price
Japanese auction
Bidders cannot tell how many others are still in, so even a lone bidder keeps confirming better prices.
Price is only part of the decision: quality, service or risk differ a lot between bidders
Sealed bids
You compare complete offers in your own time and are free to choose on more than price.
Long-standing suppliers I do not want to put through a public contest
Sealed bids
Each bids once, in confidence. Nobody is seen to be beaten on a screen.
Many items where different bidders are strong on different lots
Sealed bids or a live auction
Both let you award lot by lot or item by item. Dutch and Japanese auctions price everything as one basket.
How each one works
Sealed bids
Every bidder submits prices in confidence before a deadline. Nobody sees any bid until it passes.
- 1Bidders read the brief, accept your terms and enter a price for each item.
- 2They can replace their bid as often as they like until the deadline. Only the latest counts.
- 3At the deadline the bids open. You see them side by side and compare the ways you could award.
- Best when
- Any number of bidders. Complex requirements. Decisions that rest on more than price. Relationships you want to protect.
- Watch out for
- Bidders get one shot without knowing where they stand, so some will leave a margin. You find the market price, not necessarily each bidder's limit.
- How long it takes
- Days or weeks: bidders work in their own time.
- What bidders see during it
- Nothing about anyone else.
Live auction
Bidding happens at a set time. Bidders see their rank and improve their bids until the clock runs out. Also called an English auction.
- 1At the opening time, bidders price every item and place a bid.
- 2Each sees their position, and if you choose, the leading total. They never see who the others are.
- 3To move up they must improve by at least the step you set. A bid in the last minutes extends the clock, so nobody wins by bidding at the last second.
- Best when
- Three or more bidders who are genuinely comparable, and a specification clear enough that the cheapest acceptable bid is the one you want.
- Watch out for
- With only two bidders it can stall once one is ahead. A vague specification leads to a low price for the wrong thing. Everyone must be free at the same time.
- How long it takes
- Usually 30 to 60 minutes, plus any extensions.
- What bidders see during it
- Their own rank; optionally the leading total. Never names.
Dutch auction
The price moves by itself, step by step, towards the bidders. The first to accept the price on screen wins, and it ends at once.
- 1You set an opening price and a final price for each item, and how many steps lie between.
- 2When you are buying, the price starts low and rises; when selling, it starts high and falls. Bidders type nothing.
- 3The first bidder to press Accept wins everything at that price. If nobody accepts by the last step, there is no winner.
- Best when
- Few bidders, or prices likely to be far apart. You want a result in minutes and each bidder's own judgement of the price.
- Watch out for
- You only ever learn one price: the winner's. Your opening and final prices matter a great deal: set the range too tight and nobody accepts. Everything is awarded to one bidder as a single basket.
- How long it takes
- Minutes. With 20 steps of one minute, at most about 20 minutes.
- What bidders see during it
- The current price and the countdown to the next one. Nothing else.
Japanese auction
The price moves by itself in your favour. At every step bidders confirm they are still in, or drop out. It ends when one is left.
- 1You set an opening price and a final price for each item, and the steps between.
- 2When you are buying, the price starts high and falls; when selling, it starts low and rises.
- 3At each step every bidder must confirm to stay in. A bidder who misses a step is out, and their last confirmed price stands as their bid.
- Best when
- One or two serious bidders. Because nobody can tell how many others remain, a single bidder still has to keep confirming.
- Watch out for
- It ends as soon as one bidder is left, so the final price is set by where the second-last bidder stopped. Bidders must stay at their screen throughout. Everything is priced as a single basket.
- How long it takes
- Minutes, the same as a Dutch auction.
- What bidders see during it
- The current price and whether they are still in. Not how many others are.
Side by side
| Sealed bids | Live auction | Dutch auction | Japanese auction | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bidders needed | Any number | 3 or more | 2 or more | 1 or more |
| How long it takes | Days or weeks | 30 to 60 minutes | Minutes | Minutes |
| Bidders must be present at a set time | No | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Bidders see how they compare | No | Yes, their rank | No | No |
| Award lot by lot or item by item | Yes | Yes | No, one basket | No, one basket |
| Bids you end up with | One from each bidder | Every bidder's final bid | The winner's only | Each bidder's last confirmed price |
| Preparation for you | The brief | The brief and the rules | The brief and a price range | The brief and a price range |
Whichever you choose
- All four work for services as well as goods. For transport, list each route as its own line, priced per trip, per pallet or per mile, and choose “Services” when you set the auction up so the wording fits.
- The brief matters more than the format. Bidders who know exactly what, how much, where and on what terms will price keenly in any of the four.
- Tell bidders in advance how you will award, and keep to it. You are never obliged to accept the best price, but you record your reason if you do not.
- For a live, Dutch or Japanese auction, give bidders a few days' notice of the time. Each can rehearse in a practice round before the real thing.
- You can change the type at any time while the auction is still a draft. When you describe your situation to the assistant, it suggests a type and says why.
